Thinking about buying a two-, three-, or four-family in Boston? Smart move. Multifamily assets can combine steady cash flow, long-term appreciation, and tax advantages—plus optional “house hacking” if you live in one unit. This guide walks you through the Boston-specific lens: the property types you’ll see, how to underwrite them, what to watch out for, and tactical playbooks that actually move the needle.
1) Boston’s Multifamily Landscape, at a Glance
Typical property types
-
2–4 family homes: classic triple-deckers, brownstones split into flats, and side-by-sides. Financeable with residential loans (incl. owner-occupant options).
-
5+ units / mixed-use: commercial financing, often different underwriting and down payment requirements.
-
Condos in small associations: occasionally trade like multifamily if one owner controls multiple units.
Neighborhood patterns (high level)
-
Core neighborhoods (Back Bay, Beacon Hill, South End, Fenway/Kenmore): lower cap rates, strong appreciation, premium tenant demand.
-
Close-in neighborhoods (Jamaica Plain, Mission Hill, South Boston, Charlestown, East Boston): value-add opportunities, student/young-professional demand.
-
Outer neighborhoods (Brighton/Allston, Dorchester, Roslindale, West Roxbury, Hyde Park, Mattapan): larger buildings at a lower basis, often better cash-on-cash with thoughtful upgrades.
Tip: Focus on walkability + transit + amenities. In Boston, proximity to the T, hospitals, and universities dramatically influences rent durability and turnover risk.
2) Underwriting: A Simple, Boston-Ready Framework
Key formulas
-
EGI (Effective Gross Income) = Scheduled Rent × (1 − Vacancy %)
-
NOI (Net Operating Income) = EGI − Operating Expenses (excludes mortgage)
-
Cap Rate = NOI ÷ Purchase Price
-
Cash-on-Cash ≈ (Annual Cash Flow ÷ Initial Cash Invested)
-
DSCR = NOI ÷ Annual Debt Service (principal + interest)
Rule-of-thumb expense buckets for 2–4s
-
Property taxes, insurance, water/sewer (often landlord-paid), common-area utilities
-
Repairs & maintenance + capital reserves (e.g., 5–10% of EGI combined)
-
Snow, landscaping, trash (where applicable)
-
Property management (0–8% for small owner-operators; more if fully third-party)
Illustrative mini-case (for method, not market prediction)
-
Price: $1,500,000 for a three-family
-
Rents: $3,200/unit × 3 = $9,600/mo scheduled
-
Vacancy: 5% → EGI ≈ $9,120/mo
-
Non-debt expenses (example): taxes $1,000/mo, insurance $400, water/sewer $200, reserves/repairs 8% of EGI (~$730), other $300 → ~$2,630/mo
-
NOI ≈ $6,490/mo (≈ $77,885/yr → ~5.2% cap)
-
Financing (example): 25% down; loan ~$1.125M at 6.75%/30-yr → P&I ~$7,297/mo
-
Annual cash flow (pre-tax) ≈ NOI − Debt Service ≈ −$9,676/yr
Takeaway: In prime Boston, many stabilized purchases won’t “cash flow” out of the gate—your edge is buy-box discipline + value-add (unit upgrades, utility rebills, layout optimization) or a longer hold for appreciation and debt paydown.
3) Deal Sourcing & Fast Diligence
Where deals come from
-
On-market (MLS), boutique brokers, direct-to-owner letters, and investor networks.
-
Watch for properties listed as “estate sale,” “as-is,” “needs TLC,” or with in-place below-market rents.
30-Minute screen (before touring)
-
Rent reality check: Compare in-place vs. achievable based on similar finishes, bed/bath count, parking, and laundry.
-
Tax snapshot: Confirm current taxes and whether reassessment on sale will shift your pro forma.
-
Operating cost flags: Water/sewer high? Oil vs. gas? One heating system vs. separated? Rubber vs. pitched roofs?
-
Unit mix & layouts: 3+ bedroom stock tends to rent well to roommates; efficient 1–2 beds serve young professionals or med/grad students.
On-site diligence checklist
-
Systems: age of roof, heating plant(s), electrical panels, plumbing (galvanized vs. copper), foundation/settlement.
-
Moisture & envelope: basements, lintels, porches, fire escapes.
-
Life safety: smoke/CO devices, egress, common lights, stairwell conditions.
-
Finish level: kitchens, baths, flooring, lighting—what $ yields rent delta?
4) Boston Landlording Essentials (High Level)
This is general guidance only. Always confirm current rules with a Massachusetts real-estate attorney and the City of Boston before you buy or lease.
-
Rental registrations & inspections: Boston has registration/inspection requirements for non-owner-occupied rentals. Confirm what’s current for your property type and plan the cost/timeline.
-
Lead paint & safety: Many Boston buildings pre-date 1978. Understand lead safety obligations if renting to families with children and budget for deleading/mitigation if needed.
-
Security deposits & last month’s rent: Massachusetts has strict rules for holding, accounting, and paying interest on deposits. Mishandling is costly—use compliant forms and procedures.
-
Smoke/CO certificates: Required at transfer; confirm with the local fire department and schedule early during closing.
-
Zoning & occupancy: Verify legal unit count, use, and any restrictions on short-term or mid-term rentals before assuming ancillary income.
5) Financing Options (2–4 Units vs. 5+ Units)
2–4 units
-
Owner-occupant: Conventional or FHA options; lower down payment and better rates in exchange for living in one unit.
-
Investor: Conventional investment loans; typically higher rates/down payments.
-
Strategy: Use owner-occupant financing to reduce carrying cost while you improve units and grow income over time.
5+ units
-
Commercial loans, DSCR-driven, often 20–30-yr amortization with 5–10-yr terms.
-
Lenders focus on in-place NOI and DSCR; your rehab plan and proven operator chops matter.
Pro tips
-
Get pre-underwritten (not just pre-qualified).
-
Model sensitivity for rates (+/− 100–150 bps), rents (−5–10%), and CapEx surprises.
6) Value-Add Playbook That Works in Boston
-
Unit modernization: Clean, bright kitchens/baths; durable LVP; modern lighting; fresh paint; add dishwashers/microwaves where feasible.
-
Laundry & storage: In-unit or high-quality common laundry; secure bike storage; neat basements add perceived value.
-
Utility strategy: RUBS for water/sewer where appropriate, or separating utilities during turnovers if cost-effective.
-
Space optimization: Add a legal bedroom by reclaiming oversized living space; convert pantries/alcoves; re-configure for roommate-friendly layouts (always confirm code).
-
Amenities: Pet-friendly policies with pet rent, covered/assigned parking, secure package area, outdoor space fixes.
-
Tenant mix: Proximity to hospitals and universities supports stable demand; align finishes and messaging to that audience.
-
Operations: Professional photos, responsive maintenance, renewal outreach at 120–150 days, and modest annual increases tied to market reality.
7) House Hacking in Boston (Owner-Occupant Angle)
-
Live in one unit, rent the others to offset the mortgage.
-
Choose a unit that minimizes noise transfer and preserves privacy (top-floor often helps).
-
Prioritize buildings with strong separate systems and parking/transit to keep future tenant demand resilient.
-
Use the first 12 months to execute high-ROI, fast-turn upgrades in the vacant/on-turn units to lift income.
8) Your First 12 Months: A Practical Timeline
Months 0–2: Close & Stabilize
-
Complete rental registration and any required inspections.
-
Triage life-safety items first; set up bookkeeping and a maintenance request workflow.
Months 3–6: Low-Hanging ROI
-
Update lighting, paint, hardware, and common areas.
-
Audit water use; install low-flow fixtures where useful.
-
Capture RUBS or utility separations as leases roll.
Months 6–9: Turnover Upgrades
-
As units turn, execute targeted kitchen/bath refreshes and add in-unit laundry where feasible.
-
Re-photograph and re-market at improved rent positioning.
Months 9–12: Optimize & Refinance Prep
-
Document stabilized income/expenses; season leases.
-
If rates and NOI support it, explore rate/term or cash-out refi to recycle capital.
9) Common Pitfalls to Avoid
-
Assuming pro-forma rents without a plan to justify them.
-
Underestimating CapEx in 100-year-old buildings (porches, masonry, roofs, drain lines).
-
Ignoring deposit rules and documentation—Massachusetts is strict.
-
Skipping legal unit verification—never rely solely on a listing’s unit count.
-
Waiting too long to raise rents to market on renewal (be fair, transparent, and timely).
10) Quick Resources & Next Steps
-
Build a deal analyzer you trust (with clear inputs for taxes, insurance, water/sewer, realistic CapEx, and sensitivity toggles).
-
Line up your team: lender, RE attorney, inspector, insurance broker, lead/safety specialist, handyman/GC, plumber, electrician, photographer, and a CPA familiar with MA real-estate.
-
Start a neighborhood-by-neighborhood rent diary with actual comps and finishes—your edge compounds over time.
Bottom Line
In Boston, the winning play is rarely “set-and-forget.” It’s buy right, improve intelligently, and operate professionally. If you combine disciplined underwriting with thoughtful upgrades and rock-solid compliance, a Boston multifamily can become a durable, wealth-building cornerstone in your portfolio.